Skip to content

Your FIRE Number Is Probably Wrong

A FIRE number can give you a useful target, but one number hides assumptions about spending, taxes, pensions, inflation, and the order of investment returns.

Your FIRE Number Is Probably Wrong: A FIRE number can give you a useful target, but one number hides assumptions about spending, taxes, pensions, inflation, and the order of investment returns.

“My FIRE num­ber is €1 mil­lion.” That state­ment gives you a start­ing point, not a plan. You still need the age when you want to stop work­ing, the spend­ing you ex­pect in re­tire­ment, the date your mort­gage ends, the pen­sion in­come you ex­pect, and the taxes on your with­drawals.

Two house­holds can start with the same bal­ance and face very dif­fer­ent cash flows for the next 40 years.

Start with the 25× shortcut

The fa­mil­iar cal­cu­la­tion comes from the rec­i­p­ro­cal of a 4% with­draw­al rate. Let WW be the an­nu­al spend­ing your port­fo­lio must cover:

Target=W0.04=25×W\text{Target} = \frac{W}{0.04} = 25 \times W
The 25× shortcut

If your port­fo­lio must pro­vide €40,000 in the first re­tire­ment year, the short­cut gives you a €1 mil­lion tar­get.

€40,000First-year portfolio spending
4%Starting withdrawal rate
€1,000,00025× target

William Ben­gen’s 1994 re­search test­ed a 4% first-year with­draw­al fol­lowed by in­fla­tion ad­just­ments against his­tor­i­cal US stock, bond, and in­fla­tion data. His sam­ple sup­port­ed at least 30 years across the pe­ri­ods he stud­ied.[1] Coo­ley, Hub­bard, and Walz test­ed a wider range of rates and port­fo­lio mixes in 1998, cov­er­ing 15- to 30-year pe­ri­ods while ex­clud­ing taxes and trans­ac­tion costs.[2]

The short­cut earns its place be­cause it con­nects an­nu­al spend­ing to a clear cap­i­tal tar­get. It also com­press­es a long re­tire­ment into one num­ber, so use it for ori­en­ta­tion.

Put the number on a timeline

Your spend­ing will change. A mort­gage can end, trav­el can in­crease dur­ing the first re­tire­ment decade, chil­dren can leave home, and large costs can ar­rive in spe­cif­ic years. A bank state­ment from last year gives every fu­ture year the same shape. A pro­jec­tion lets each pe­ri­od have its own spend­ing level.

Taxes cre­ate an­oth­er gap. If you need €40,000 after tax and as­sume a 15% ef­fec­tive tax rate, your port­fo­lio would need to pro­vide about €47,059 be­fore tax.

Gross withdrawal=€40,0001−0.15≈€47,059\text{Gross withdrawal} = \frac{€40{,}000}{1 - 0.15} \approx €47{,}059
Simplified gross withdrawal

Ir­reg­u­lar costs de­serve dates too. A €12,000 ren­o­va­tion every 12 years can be­come a €1,000 an­nu­al re­serve, or you can place the full cost in the year you ex­pect to pay it. The sec­ond ap­proach shows how the ex­pense in­ter­acts with a mar­ket de­cline.

Pen­sions and other in­come re­duce the port­fo­lio gap, but only after they begin. Ana might need €40,000 from her port­fo­lio be­tween ages 50 and 59, then €10,000 after a €18,000 pen­sion be­gins at 67 and her mort­gage ends. Mul­ti­ply­ing €10,000 by 25 ig­nores the 17-year bridge. Mul­ti­ply­ing €40,000 by 25 ig­nores the later pen­sion.

Choose ei­ther real euros through­out or nom­i­nal euros with in­fla­tion ap­plied to fu­ture cash flows. Do not mix both meth­ods.

Test the return sequence

A long-run av­er­age re­turn does not ar­rive in a smooth line. Mar­kets can fall dur­ing the first re­tire­ment years and re­cov­er later. With­drawals make the order mat­ter be­cause as­sets sold after a fall can­not par­tic­i­pate in the re­cov­ery.

Test a poor first five years sep­a­rate­ly. A plan that sur­vives a smooth 5% re­turn path can fail after an early draw­down even when the long-run av­er­age ends near 5%.

Build the target in six checks

  1. Es­ti­mate re­tire­ment spend­ing in today’s money and sep­a­rate re­cur­ring costs from large ir­reg­u­lar costs.
  2. Add mort­gage end dates, rent changes, planned moves, or other hous­ing shifts.
  3. Add pen­sions, ben­e­fits, rental in­come, and later work in the years they begin.
  4. Model taxes on the in­come and with­drawals your ac­counts can pro­duce.
  5. Choose a hori­zon that fits your age in­stead of bor­row­ing a 30-year hori­zon by habit.
  6. Com­pare an early re­tire­ment date with later dates and stress-test bad early re­turns.

Fignis can help you com­pare those as­sump­tions with­out forc­ing one fore­cast to carry the whole de­ci­sion. Build a base case, change the re­tire­ment date or pen­sion tim­ing, and com­pare the port­fo­lio paths.

Use €1 mil­lion if it helps you track progress, but keep the as­sump­tions be­side it. Write down the re­tire­ment age, spend­ing basis, with­draw­al method, pen­sion dates, tax treat­ment, and re­turn sce­nar­ios. Re­cal­cu­late when any of them changes.

Build the wider FI planConnect your target with savings, portfolio growth, and the years between financial independence and later retirement income.Examine the withdrawal-rate benchmarkSee how 3%, 4%, and 5% starting rates change the capital target and the risks you take.
Back to blogGet Started